Only reason for the 4 star as I feel it runs smaller than the sizing chart. I would have ordered a size larger but it didn't come larger. I am new to motorcycle riding. I love this jacket. It's not too heavy for a beginner who is just getting used to all the protective clothing. It fit snug but I did feel that the waist area was a little small. I feel that the sizing charts are not true to size compared to the actual sizing of the jacket but I love it and will keep it.